How Dutch Brothers Brews Brand Loyalty with Stickers

In the highly competitive coffee industry, it takes more than great drinks to stand out. Dutch Brothers, the popular drive-thru coffee chain, has found an ingenious way to foster a loyal customer base—and it doesn’t rely solely on caffeine. One of their most effective strategies? Monthly sticker giveaways.

At first glance, giving away stickers may seem simple. But dig deeper, and you’ll see how this tactic serves as a cornerstone of their marketing approach, creating excitement, driving repeat business, and turning customers into brand advocates. Here’s how Dutch Brothers’ sticker giveaway days offer lessons every business can apply.

The Power of Exclusivity

One of the most compelling elements of Dutch Brothers’ stickers is their exclusivity. Each month, they release a new, limited-edition design that’s only available for a short time, and often, only to customers who make a purchase. This strategy taps into the basic human desire for rare and exclusive items—creating a sense of urgency that drives immediate action.

For business owners, this strategy can be applied in many ways. Offering exclusive items, whether it's a product, service, or collectible, encourages customers to act quickly and ensures your brand stays top of mind. Consider how limited-time offers or special items can add urgency to your campaigns.

Building a Community

Dutch Brothers doesn’t just see customers—they see a community. The brand has cultivated a loyal following, and their monthly sticker giveaways have become an integral part of that community-building effort. Customers proudly display these stickers on laptops, water bottles, and cars, turning them into mini billboards for the brand.

What makes this effective is that customers feel they’re part of something bigger. The sticker becomes a symbol of belonging to the “Dutch Fam,” as they call it. Every business owner should ask themselves: how can I create a sense of community among my customers? How can I encourage them to represent my brand proudly in their everyday lives?

Low-Cost, High-Impact Marketing

One of the brilliant things about Dutch Brothers’ sticker giveaways is that they’re low-cost but offer significant return on investment. For the cost of printing a small sticker, Dutch Brothers creates buzz that can last all month long. These stickers spark conversations, increase brand visibility, and foster deeper connections with customers—all for a minimal investment.

If you’re a business owner, think about how you can replicate this strategy. What simple, low-cost promotional items can you offer that will keep your brand in customers’ minds and conversations? Stickers, magnets, or even digital content are all budget-friendly ways to keep your brand visible.

Fostering Repeat Business

The limited-edition nature of these stickers drives customers back through the door month after month. By consistently releasing new designs, Dutch Brothers ensures that loyal customers have a reason to return regularly. This type of ongoing engagement helps increase lifetime customer value—a key metric for business growth.

What’s more, these monthly drops turn routine visits into a treasure hunt. Customers feel a sense of anticipation and reward for returning regularly. For business owners, offering something fresh and new on a regular basis—whether it’s a new product, promotion, or piece of branded merchandise—can encourage customers to come back again and again.

Conclusion

The success of Dutch Brothers' sticker giveaways has not gone unnoticed by competitors, with brands like Starbucks starting to catch on. On the first day of fall, Starbucks launched their own sticker sheet giveaway to customers, signaling that the competition is heating up. Despite this, Dutch Brothers remains ahead of the curve, continuing to innovate with their promotions. Recently, they gave away exclusive branded rubber ducks, further cementing their reputation for creative, customer-engaging giveaways. This commitment to unique, branded merchandise keeps Dutch Brothers at the forefront of customer loyalty initiatives.

If you’re inspired by Dutch Brothers' marketing success, you don’t have to be in the coffee industry to replicate their strategy. Custom stickers are a simple, effective, and affordable way to build brand loyalty, spark conversations, and keep your business top of mind.

Ready to take your marketing to the next level? Contact Sneeze It today and let’s design custom stickers that will make your brand stick—literally.

Want to learn how Sneeze it can help you take your marketing to the next level? Schedule a meeting below!